Best Broiler Pans – Top 8 Reviews and Buying Guide 2020

Broiler pans are great accessories in your kitchen; they make cooking more comfortable and much faster. The products come in a unique design looking like a baking sheet, and it allows you to ensure the food nutrients, vitamins, and other minerals in your vegetables, meats remain intact as you cook. Consequently, you must purchase the best broiler pans available in the market.

What is a Broiling Pan?

A broiling pan refers to a cooktop-accessory that is of great use in your kitchen, as it makes your cooking easier. The pan is shaped like a baking sheet (in size and design), however unlike the baking sheet, the broiler pan has a rack placed at the top to allow moisture drip off into the bottom tray; in other words, a broiler pan has two components; a rack and a tray.

The broiler pan is also called broiler roaster, oven broiling pan, or oven roaster. It is made of stainless steel or heavy gauge steel and black porcelain enamel. It can be used to broil foods in the oven, including roasts, steaks, meats, poultry, and even your vegetables. The food is placed on the rack to cook, and then drippings are collected in the tray below. For this reason, the broiler pan is very healthy and safe, giving you a wonderful cooking experience.

Top 8 Best Broiler Pans in The Market

Rank

Pan

Image

Material

Price

#1

Farberware Bakeware Broiler Pan

Steel

#2

GE WB48X10056 OEM Broiler Pan

Enameled steel

#3

Whirlpool 4396923 Broiler Pan

Porcelain

#4

Range Kleen BP106X 2 PC Broiler Pan

Porcelain

#5

Frigidaire 5304442087 Broiler Pan

No-data

#6

Granite Ware Broiler Pan

Carbon Steel

#7

Norpro Broiler Pan

Stainless Steel

#8

Handi-Foil Aluminum Foil Disposable Broiler Pan

Aluminum

Before purchasing a broiler pan, you should consider several factors; these factors include the construction and its associative features. You also want to check if it is easy to use and clean after that, and your budget. Many cookware brands that manufacture broiler pans are rampant in the market, so we believe that the decision-making process can be very tedious and confusing. If not done correctly, you could make the wrong choice.

Consequently, given that several broiler pans are available for purchase in the market, our team of experts took the time to study these products carefully. Finally, we came up with an 8-item list containing the best broiler pans available for purchase. 

1. Farberware Bakeware Broiler Pan - Most Recommended

If you require a broiler pan that you can clean easily, this pan by the Farberware brand is a fantastic option. The pan has a nonstick inner surface, which does the cleaning after cooking very easy. The nonstick surface helps to release the food quickly from the pan after cooking and hence can be seen as one of the best nonstick broilers pan available. It is also oven save to a temperature of about 450 degrees Fahrenheit. The deep pan has a dimension of 11-inch by 15-inch and features a chrome-plated rack, which is removable and can be used to raise the meat that allows fats to drip off easily.

Furthermore, the broiler pan has a dual-riveted handle made of stainless steel and are very easy to grip. They enable you to take out your pan from the oven. The rack also features wider handles that aids in the removal of roasts. The rack is flat, the roaster pan is made of heavy-duty steel, and both offer you a quality cooking experience. Lastly, the product can last for a long time, resisting warping and providing you with fantastic roasting performance.

Pros and Benefits

  • Nonstick roaster pan.
  • Flat rack.
  • Heavy-duty steel roaster pan.
  • Dual-riveted handles.
  • Comfortable to hold handles.
  • Removable chrome-plated rack.
  • Durable and long-lasting.

2. GE WB48X10056 OEM Broiler Pan

This broiler pan by the General Electric cookware brand is also a great product you should purchase for your culinary purposes. The pan is a Genuine Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) that has been designed based on exact specifications, so there are no approximations about the size and dimensions. The broiler pan is one of the best broiler pans for oven stovetops as the product is a gas range, stove, and oven safe.

The pan features a grill (rack) and bottom pan; the rack helps to hold the food while the bottom pan collects the drippings while the food cooks. The pan has been manufactured with high premium materials, which guarantees its durability, and comes with the manufacturer’s manual, including specifications for installation. You can quickly repair the appliances if it gets spoilt.

Pros and Benefits

  • Genuine OEM.
  • Designed to exact specifications.
  • Oven safe.
  • Includes grill and bottom pan.
  • High-quality materials.
  • Very durable.
  • Used with gas range and various stovetops

3. Whirlpool 4396923 Broiler Pan

This whirlpool broiler pan model is a Factory Certified Accessory; this statement translates to the fact that the product has quality parts and added accessories that are designed particularly for your device. The time-tested engineering of the product meets strict quality specifications. This durable porcelain broiler pan is regarded as one of the best broiler pans for steaks and can be used to make healthy meals such as meats, vegetables, etc.

In addition to that, the product features a black porcelain rack, a porcelain pan, also black, and a metal grid.  It can be used to accommodate a large amount of food simultaneously, thus suitable for cooking for your large family and making it one of the best broiler pans for oven. Moreover, the rack helps to hold the food above the grid tray, allowing excess fat to drip to the bottom and ensure air circulation evenly as you cook. Finally, the product is dishwasher safe making cleaning very easy.

Pros and Benefits

  • Durable nonstick porcelain.
  • Very large.
  • Even heat distribution.
  • Dishwasher safe.
  • Oven safe.
  • For broiling meats, veggies, etc.

4. Range Kleen BP106X 2 PC Broiler Pan

This broiler pan is most preferred for its versatility as it can be used to cook several dishes, including fish. The pan is made of heavy-duty porcelain, which makes it very durable. It features two parts; the broiler rack and the broiler tray. The rack holds your food in place while excess fats drip into the plate. The pan is also designed to enable even heat distribution, ensuring your food is adequately cooked within and outside.

Additionally, the pan is one of the best nonstick broilers pan available, as its nonstick surface allows you to cook multiple types of food without any sticky remnants messing your pan. The pan has a dimension of 12.75" by 8.5" by 1.325," making it large enough to serve as a baking dish. Lastly, the pan is oven-safe, allowing you to move from stove to oven quickly, and it is dishwasher safe. This way, you need not stress about how to clean it after you are done with cooking.

Pros and Benefits

  • Heavy-duty porcelain.
  • Nonstick coating.
  • For broiling, grilling, and baking.
  • Dishwasher safe.
  • Oven safe.
  • Even heat distribution.

5. Frigidaire 5304442087 Broiler Pan

Are you searching for more other cookware that would be a perfect fit for your oven? Then look no further; Frigidaire 5304442087 broiler pan is the ideal answer; little wonder it is seen as one of the best broiler pans for oven. The broiler pan, which comes in a beautiful color (blue), has a nonstick surface convenient for cooking your meals such as meat, fish, poultry, and vegetables.

Besides, the nonstick feature ensures effortless food release after cooking and enables you to clean efficiently without stress. The pan can also withstand high temperature and is resistant to warping, thus enforcing its durability and ensuring it lasts longer than your regular broiler pan.  Finally, it has a drip tray that collects excess fats from the food contained in the rack above. And the thick porcelain enables even distribution of heat.

Pros and Benefits

  • Best for oven use.
  • Even distribution of heat.
  • Nonstick surface.
  • Warp resistant.
  • Very durable.
  • Easy to clean.

6. Granite Ware Broiler Pan

This is a fantastic product from the Granite Ware shop as it is unarguably one of the most versatile broilers pans you can find in the market. The product has three associated pieces in each set; a broiling grate, broiling rack, and a bottom tray, consequently allowing you to broil, bake, and grill any food of your choice.

Moreover, the accessories that come with this product are all made of carbon steel core, a feature that allows you to prepare your meals faster while ensuring even heat distribution as you cook. Hence you can use the broiler pan for cooking your meat, poultry, fish, etc. readily while assured of the healthy result. Finally, the broiler pan is free from PFOA, PTFE, and other toxic chemicals that could be harmful to you. It is also dishwasher safe making cleaning easy after cooking.

Pros and Benefits

  • Energy-efficient carbon steel core.
  • For broiling, baking, and grilling.
  • Nonstick porcelain surface.
  • Free of PFOA, PTFE, etc.
  • Dishwasher safe.
  • Even heat distribution.

7. Norpro Broiler Pan

If you are searching for a stainless-steel broiler pan that is very sturdy and durable, the Norpro broiler pan is the best fit for you. The pan is regarded as amongst the best stainless-steel broiler pan due to its sturdy stainless-steel component. It has two utensils accompany it, made of stainless steel, the broiler pack and the tray. The rack with perforations helps remove the excess fat and oil contained in the food, allowing it to drip into the tray below, thus ensuring your food is healthy for consumption.

Furthermore, the broiler pan is oven safe allowing you to transition from stove to oven, and because the tray is equally made of stainless steel, your oven is kept looking clean while you are cooking. You can use the product to prepare fish, meat ribs, vegetables, poultry, etc. enough for one individual or a maximum of two persons. It is also dishwasher safe, making cleaning after use easy and stress-free.

Pros and Benefits

  • For 1-2 person servings.
  • Stainless steel tray and rack.
  • Dishwasher safe.
  • Oven safe.
  • Very sturdy and durable.
  • Ensures healthy cooking results.

8. Handi-Foil Aluminum Foil Disposable Broiler Pan

Your broiling can also be done outdoors using disposable broiler pans like the Handi-Foil disposable broiler pan. Hence to successfully facilitate your outdoor cooking, you should consider this product. They are very portable and efficient, helping you to collect grease from your food, thus preventing any form of mess.

The product manufactured by the Handi-Foil brand, who had the end-user’s interest in mind when manufacturing the product, is considerably easy to use once and can be discarded easily. The product quantity ranges from 10, 25, 50, 100, and 200 disposable aluminum foil packs available depending on the buyer's request.

Pros and Benefits

  • Best for outdoor broiling.
  • Very portable.
  • Easy to use and discard.
  • Comes in packs.
  • Nonstick feature.
  • Does not require cleaning.

Best Broiler Pans - Buying Guide

In buying a new broiler pan, you have to consider several factors; these factors would guide you to make the right decision when you go to the market. This is because there are different broiler cookware brands aside from the ones we highlighted in this article, which are inarguably the best option to meet your broiling needs. And so, to make it easier for you to decide which product you want, we have highlighted some factors that you should consider before buying. They include the following features.

The Construction Material

This can be said to be an essential feature worthy of note, maybe because it is the primary determinant of several capabilities that would be exhibited by your broiler pan. Hence when buying, ensure you spend time going through the product detail, check the type of material used in construction, the durability of the material, and how it is designed.

You should also check if it has a nonstick surface to ensure you cook without spraying butter or oil, hence making your food healthy. It would be best if you had a broiler pan with high construction as it would help distribute heat evenly, thus making your cooking safe and healthy. Generally, you should check if it has an aluminum layer, has a nonstick porcelain surface, has a stainless-steel handle, and has a carbon steel core for effective heat management. These are the main points you should put into consideration in terms of construction material.

Size

This factor is equally important. You need a broiler pan that has excellent features and can also fit easily into your oven. Buying a big pan that can’t fit in your oven is a wasted effort. You also need a broiler pan that can accommodate your family's needs, either large or small. So put that also in mind when buying your pan. This way, you purchase a pan that fits in your oven and also meets your cooking needs.

Ease of Cleaning

This factor is also vital; you want a broiler pan that can be easily cleaned and maintained after cooking. So, when buying, you should also check if it is also dishwasher safe as that will help you save time while cooking, thus preventing you from making a mess. Besides, most broiler pans are dishwasher safe; therefore, it would be easy to spot. However, it is advisable you hand wash sometimes to ensure it lasts longer.

Function

It would be best to buy a versatile product and be used for other purposes aside from broiling’s, such as baking, grilling, and toasting. Having such a product is cost-effective, saves time, and also saves storage space.

How To Use Broiler Pan?

The broiling process involves dry heat to cook meat, poultry, veggies, etc., for about 5-15 minutes. To use a broiler pan, you need to first arrange or set the perforated or draining rack on top of the bottom tray. Next, you'll need to organize the food on top of the rack, leaving space between each piece of meat (food) to enable even cooking and to ensure the free flow of air as you cook the food. Then you wait for the food to get cooked.

As a result, after cooking, the food has a brown outer surface and tastes like caramel.

Conclusion

A broiler has several associated benefits when used in the kitchen. It saves you cooking time, ensures your cooking is healthier, safer, and makes you consume your food with less fat than usual while allowing even heat distribution as you cook. This is why having a broiler pan is beneficial for your culinary purposes.

Therefore, to enable you to make your decisions more comfortable, we have listed 8 best broiler pans. These pans have been selected based on their features and also their functions. We have also considered them based on budget-friendliness and the quality they give, so whatever your needs, these top best 8 broiler pans are the best choice for preparing your meat, fish, poultry, and vegetables.

Leave a Comment